Israel Jeers Amnesty International Report

A Palestinian rides his bicycle alongside Israel's controversial separation barrier in the West Bank town of Qalqilya, January 2007. Israel has rejected criticism by Amnesty International over its vast barrier in the occupied West Bank, saying Palestinian suicide bombers are to blame for the controversial structure.(AFP/File/Jaafar Ashtiyeh)

Israel rejects Amnesty criticism over barrier

June 4, 2007

JERUSALEM (AFP) -Israel on Monday rejected criticism by Amnesty International over its vast barrier in the occupied West Bank, saying Palestinian suicide bombers are to blame for the controversial structure.

"Amnesty's report is one-sided, immoral, and riddled with mistakes and numerous factual and legal inaccuracies, including scant mention of Palestinian terrorism," the justice ministry said in a statement.

"The report does not relate -- in any acceptable manner -- to Israel's right of self-defence or to its legitimate security needs, but mentions these needs only casually, without giving them their due consideration.

"Israel views with the utmost importance the safeguarding of human rights and invests abundant resources in doing so," it said.

In its report on the 40th anniversary of the Israeli occupation of the Palestinian territories, the London-based human rights group said Israel had plunged the Palestinians into unprecedented levels of poverty but failed to assure its own security.

"The Palestinians are responsible for their lot," Deputy Prime Minister Shimon Peres told public radio.

"The enormous problems caused by the security barrier are the consequences of the second intifada and the buses that the Palestinian suicide bombers coming from the West Bank exploded in Israel.

"Each state must protect its nationals and the security barrier was erected to prevent these attacks, which have practically stopped since it was put up," he said.

Amnesty said Israel could not justify building the barrier, much of which lies on Palestinian land inside the West Bank, and spoke out against the more than 500 Israeli checkpoints and blockades in the West Bank.

"We are trying to reduce the number of roadblocks in the West Bank to ease traffic, but at the same time the Palestinian terrorist organisations try to take advantage of this to carry out attacks in Israel," Peres said.

Israel says the 700 kilometre (435 mile) long barrier, made up of concrete walls and razor wire fences, is necessary to protect the Jewish state against attacks.

Palestinians say the "apartheid wall" is a land grab which eats up chunks of their promised state, separates farmers from their land and splits entire communities and families.

~~~~~~~~

Israel/OPT: Forty years of occupation -- no security without basic rights

Amnesty International

June 4, 2007

On the eve of the 40th anniversary of Israel’s occupation of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, Amnesty International today called on the Israeli authorities to end the land-grabbing, blockades and other violations of international law carried out under the occupation. These have resulted in widespread human rights abuses and have also failed to bring security to the Israeli and Palestinian civilian populations.

A 45-page report published today, Enduring Occupation: Palestinian under siege in the West Bank, illustrates the devastating impact of four decades of Israeli military occupation. The report documents the relentless expansion of unlawful settlements on occupied land that deprives the Palestinian population of crucial resources and documents a plethora of measures that confine Palestinians to fragmented enclaves and hinder their access to work, health and education facilities. These measures include a 700km fence/wall, more than 500 checkpoints and blockades, and a complicated system of permits.

"Palestinians living in the West Bank are blocked at every turn. This is not simply an inconvenience -- it can be a matter of life or death. It is unacceptable that women in labour, sick children, or victims of accidents on their way to hospital should be forced to take long detours and face delays which can cost them their lives," said Malcolm Smart, Director for Amnesty International's Middle East and North Africa Programme.

"International action is urgently needed to address the widespread human rights abuses being committed under the occupation, and which are fuelling resentment and despair among a predominantly young and increasingly radicalized Palestinian population," said Malcolm Smart. "For forty years, the international community has failed adequately to address the Israeli-Palestinian problem; it cannot, must not, wait another forty years to do so."

Amnesty International is calling for the urgent deployment of an effective international human rights monitoring mechanism to monitor compliance by both parties, Israeli and Palestinian, with their obligations under international law. This must be backed up with a commitment to investigate and prosecute, through the exercise of universal jurisdiction, those who commit war crimes or other crimes under international law.

"We do not underestimate the difficulties of establishing such an independent monitoring system, whether by the UN or another appropriate body, but it is vital that the international community should become more engaged in finding a solution, and in holding the parties to their obligations under international law," said Malcolm Smart.

In its report, Amnesty International acknowledges Israel’s legitimate security concerns and the government’s obligation to protect the population within its borders, but says this does not justify blatant violations of international law, such as construction of much of the fence/wall inside the West Bank on Palestinian land.

"If the intention was simply to prevent Palestinian suicide bombers from entering Israel, the barrier would be located on the Green Line, the border between Israel and the West Bank," said Malcolm Smart. "Yet, the reality is that most of it is being built on Palestinian land, in defiance of the International Court of Justice, and is separating Palestinian towns and villages in the West Bank."

In addition to the fence/wall, the movement of Palestinians is several constrained by a host of other restrictions, including over 500 checkpoints and blockades, and a network of roads for Israeli settlers to use and off-limits to Palestinians. The barrier, together with these roads and roadblocks, benefit continuously expanding but unlawful Israeli settlements and make them territorially contiguous with Israel.

"Harsh Israeli restrictions have caused the virtual collapse of the Palestinian economy and are exacerbating the increasingly fragile conditions in which Palestinians live and work -- resulting in levels of despair, poverty and food insecurity never before seen in the Occupied Palestinian Territories," said Malcolm Smart.

"Most Palestinians are now relying on aid for subsistence, with families reducing the quality and quantity of the food they consume and selling assets essential for their livelihoods."

Amnesty International is calling on the Israeli authorities to:

• 
  lift the regime of blockades and restrictions on Palestinians in the OPT, which constitute collective punishment, and ensure that restrictions imposed in response to specific security threats only target the individuals concerned -- not entire communities.


• 
  halt the construction of the fence/wall inside the West Bank, and remove the sections already built there;


• 
  cease the construction or expansion of Israeli settlements and related infrastructure in the OPT as a first step towards removing Israeli settlements and "outposts";


• 
  cancel all demolition orders on homes in the OPT, and provide reparation to Palestinians whose homes and properties have already been destroyed.

The organization is also reiterating its call on Palestinian armed groups to end immediately attacks on civilians and on the Palestinian Authority (PA) to take effective action to stop and prevent such attacks and bring to justice those responsible.

To see a full copy of the report, please go to http://web.amnesty.org/library/index/engmde150332007

Part1

Part 2